Crist Blog | February 03, 2008
Feast or Famine

This was a racing weekend where it felt like there was too much going on Saturday and not enough on Sunday -- a passel of interesting stakes races and multirace bets one day, another Santa Anita cancellation and some awfully watery black type the next.
Saturday also saw the first two Grade 1 races of 2008, and both featured inexplicably dismal off-the-board performances by legitimate odds-on favorites. First in the Donn, Daaher crumbled when confronted with tag-team early pressure through fast fractions. Spring at Last pushed him through an opening quarter of 22.95, then wisely was wrestled back, and 46-1 Kiss the Kid was at the favorite's throat through a half in 46.26 and six furlongs in 1:09.72. Daaher cracked first and was finished at the top of the stretch, then Spring at Last easily went past Kiss the Kid and held off A.P. Arrow through a tiring final furlong of 13.50 to win by half a length in 1:48.35.
The outcome may have sent the winner and favorite into different races in Dubai March 29 than had initially been planned. Daaher, if he checks out okay in the wake of his early surrender, may try the Godolphin Mile instead of the 10-furlong Dubai World Cup while Spring at Last, the '07 Mile winner, may now stretch out in the main event.
It's way too soon to write off Daaher after one race. His Jerome and Cigar Mile were legitimately fast races and he still has the right to rebound and the potential to improve with age. Still, when he regroups he'll have to prove he can handle early pressure and negotiate two turns against top company.
The Donn got a Beyer Speed Figure of 107, as did the G2 Strubt at Santa Anita later in the afternoon, where Montyerey Jazz speed-popped the field and cruised to a 4 1/2-length victory over the perpetually overbet Tiago. Given that the final time of the Strub was three seconds faster than the Donn, and how quickly Santa Anita's damaged Cushion Track is playing, Monterey Jazz actually got away with pretty moderate fractions -- 22.76, 45.89 and 1:08.10. He was 7 in front at that point, and came home in 37.55 for (another) track-record clocking of 1:45.65.
While there may have been some reasons to oppose Daaher on grounds of pace and distance, the result of the afternoon's other Grade 1 was utterly baffling. When Pussycat Doll was scratched from the Santa Monica Saturday morning with a foot abcess, Hystericalady appeared to tower over four outclassed rivals and was understandably pounded to 3-10. But she barely ran a step and faded to fourth behind the improbable 26-1 Intangaroo, who had taken five tries to win her N1x condition with a Beyer of 86, 9 to 22 points lower than any of the favorite's last seven efforts. The stunned winning connections said afterwards they were just hoping to clunk up for third in a short G1 field, but congratulations to them and to you if you found a reason to like her.
The afternoon's two Grade 2 stakes races for potential Derby candidates came up a bit on the slow side. At Santa Anita, third-time starter Crown of Thorns (by Repent) got only a 93 Beyer winning the five-horse Robert Lewis with a perfect rail trip in 1:40.76 for a mile and a sixteenth. At Gulfstream, Eaton's Gift (by Johannesburg) also got a 93 for his 3 1/2-length victory in the Swale, where he went 6 1/2 furlongs in 1:15.63. A marginally better figure was awarded to Barrier Reef (by Mizzen Mast), who got a 94 winning the ungraded Whirlaway at Aqueduct on a tricky, windy afternoon where the routes seemed to be playing faster than the sprints.
One of those sprints is the clubhouse leader for Most Dismal Race of the Winter in New York: The sixth, a six-furlong race for $25k statebred maiden claimers. was won by ReturntoKarakorum in 1:15.20 -- good for a winning Beyer of 37.
That race knocked me out in the first leg of the Aqueduct late pick four, so I reloaded and played the late pick three, getting alive to four horses, including 62-1 Fast Iz a Turtle, who has been good to me in the past and who I thought might just be poised for improvement second time back off a long layoff. Turned out he was but, alas, a hoped-for speed duel failed to materialize and 8-1 Strummer wired the field. F.I.A.T., however, flew home for second and my insanity-insurance exacta backwheel paid $859 for $2, neutralizing a multitude if not an entirety of parimutuel failures the rest of the day, including a dreadful 2-for-5 performance in the Magna 5.
That wager, which paid only $382 in its seasonal debut last week amid the Sunshine Millions chalkfest, failed to attract its $500,000 guaranteed pool, coming up light by about $50,000. So the $16,956.40 payoff was about 10 percent higher than it should have been, with Magna making up the shortfall. There has to be a compelling multirace wager for Magna to construct in the winter, but this isn't it. If Magna feels obliged to start the wager each week with a race from Laurel, which hubs the bet, it at least should complete the sequence with two races each from Gulfstream and Santa Anita instead of adding Golden Gate to the mix.
The bet, which also might attract a much larger pool of players with a $1 instead of $2 minimum, has not captured the public imagination and now it's not even hitting its guaranteed minimums.
Posted by Steven Crist Feb 3, 2008 8:35:36 PM | Permalink
Keywords:
Comments
traci says:
I'm actually a huge fan of Intangaroo. I was not surprised at all when she won! But then, I'm really a 'hopeless romantic' kind of horse racing fan...I like a good story.
I was upset that I was too ill to be at the track and bet on her and they don't allow on-line betting in Texas. Grrr. Maybe one day, they'll catch up with the rest of the world and realize it's my money to spend as I see fit! At least I got to watch it live on CalRacing.com. They're a life-saver.
Posted by Traci Feb 13, 2008 3:48:35 AM
andyscoggin says:
Steve,
How do you feel about the Ky. Derby Futures betting??? Do you ever make any plays??
Posted by AndyScoggin Feb 6, 2008 1:19:25 PM
otbtony says:
Steve,
Is Barrier Reef legit? His maiden win, though slow, awed me. Can't believe he was 5-1. A taste?
Posted by otbtony Feb 5, 2008 9:23:29 PM
george_quinn says:
Your a class act jeff to step up. rfb0318 forget about pat valenzuela I would not let him walk my golden retreiver.
George in Lexington Ky.
Posted by george quinn Feb 5, 2008 10:42:00 AM
wayne80 says:
One thing Magna has done right is resist installing "all weather" surfaces unless mandated.
The installed brand new dirt tracks at LRL and GULF that are working out just fine.
Posted by Wayne80 Feb 5, 2008 9:28:47 AM
ejxd2 says:
I admire Steve's candor on the Magna 5 considering Magna spends a lot of money advertising the bet in Daily Racing Form.
How are we judging that this is a failure? Because it hasn't reached the guarantee its first two weeks? It's still handling $400k+, which is a lot compared to other pools.
People who keep saying Laurel should card high level allowance races or a stakes for the Magna 5 lose credibility because the sequence nearly always (including both times this year) starts with a stakes race from Laurel.
Admittedly, the race from Golden Gate is harder to explain.
The folks at Magna want to see this generate some carryovers, which it would never do at the $1 base. Having said that, there have been so few carryovers of the bet, it might be better to attract more players with a $1 min.
Posted by EJXD2 Feb 5, 2008 9:11:40 AM
hrhjlambert says:
Hey Crist,
If you really want people to take your prognostication seriously, you are going to need to attempt to explain the real racing anomolies. The biggest one recently is the putrid performance by the Hystericalady team at Santa Anita. Any theories?
Posted by hrhjlambert Feb 5, 2008 2:40:13 AM
kevroc says:
Santa Anita's pick six carryover is gonna be fun this weekend (Friday or Saturday, to be determined).
I think it'll be more fun if it's on Saturday with the two Grade I's and one Grade II.
Also, we're prolly gonna see full fields the rest of the way out there what with the horsemen looking to give their charges some work already...
$181k, let's go get it! (whenever they decide to run again...)
Posted by kevroc Feb 5, 2008 2:15:27 AM
c says:
"on the laughably named 'Cushion Track'"
Steve Davidowitz,
Bravo. I posted a nearly identical comment on Dan Illman's blog last week. Get ready to defend yourself.
Posted by C Feb 4, 2008 11:38:49 PM
tony_ says:
As for the donn sat wouldn't you agree that Dahere did not lose the race by himself. Mike luzzi's ride lost the race by going out to the front ! The race is a mile an eighth !! The minute i saw him go winging out to the lead I knew he'd be dead @ the end on that track . The 1st thing I said was there goes Mike Luzzi's big chance @ riding this horse ever again . There's a reason why these guys don't get the big horses . I also thought Ramon Dominguez had a fantastic ride and almost got there @ the end . As for Magna yes they are a mess and not good for the game . The racing game as much as I love it just seems to be in a mess right now . The polytrack, ,OTB going broke , and the NYRA soap opera . Its just Ridiculous.
Posted by Tony Feb 4, 2008 11:08:16 PM
jeff says:
Props to George_quinn
Have to give credit where credit is due....I would not have beleived it if I hadn't seen it with my own eyes.
I am a season Patriots ticket holder and it kills me to say it...but congratulations to the "World Champion New York Giants".
Pitchers and catchers please report...On to the Red Sox !!!
Posted by jeff Feb 4, 2008 9:36:14 PM
ponyman says:
Dahar--after looking at photo of Dahar and putting it on my desktop photo---How could that horse lose---never seen a horse look so fit---
Posted by ponyman Feb 4, 2008 7:59:08 PM
vegan says:
Didn't Teleprompter run the first 6f. in 1:27 or so in the Arlington Million ? Even mighty Greinton could not run him down after that.
Posted by vegan Feb 4, 2008 7:47:11 PM
steve_davidowitz says:
Steve, I have said and written in several forums that I think all of the new track and world records' that have been set at Santa Anita on the laughably named 'Cushion Track' should be labeled with an asterisk, and/or completely disregarded for a set of new track records yet to be set when the Pro-Ride-Cushion Track mixture comes into play, we think, sometime soon.
What do you think about these records and how would you handle them if you were running Santa Anita, or posing as an arbitrator of track and world records for the American Racing Manual and other statistical reference works?
Posted by Steve Davidowitz Feb 4, 2008 6:18:34 PM
cayman01 says:
I think if the Magna 5 was a $1 they'd get more action they can handle. The $2 minimum cost me $17k this weekend as my bankroll isn't big enough to cover any 3 A's
with 2 B's tickets. I had all five winners, but only four of five on two different tix.
Vanderlaay and Spring At Last
were B horses for me.At a $1 wager I would have had them covered together.
What i learned: Don't single a speed horse (Daaher) coming off the bench against plenty of other early speed ( K the K, S.A.L,Fairbanks et al).
Posted by cayman01 Feb 4, 2008 2:54:18 PM
92_leatherneck says:
I agree with 'jcp' that the Magna 5 payoff was pretty sweet this week. That's why I play. I also agree that it's expensive, but conversely, I don't want a ton of winners in the mix that would result from the $0.50 or $1 wagers. The way that I personally defray the cost is by partnering with 1 or 2 friends. This week, we put in a $168 play that we split in half and so my loss (for getting 3 of 5) was $84. Not too bad when you consider that we could've (and really should've) won $17k.
We missed the 1st race at Laurel by dropping off the leading rider (Napravnik) from our bet -- STUPID!! We also realized that Spring at Last was going to win if Daaher did not, but only after the Magna 5 started - GRRRrrrr.
Anyway, I thought picking the winners in all 5 races was utterly achievable this week as it was last week when we got 4 of 5. What I think really needs done instead is that all tracks/owners/TV stations unite to provide an NFL-like experience for the sport. That, above all, would take this sport to the next level and drag the Magna 5 along with it.
Posted by 92 LeatherNeck Feb 4, 2008 2:31:06 PM
rfb0318 says:
I wish that I had this many chances in life:
VALENZUELA COMING: Jockey Patrick Valenzuela will arrive at the Fair Grounds on Thursday and wants to begin riding by Saturday or Sunday, said Danny Gargan, who will be Valenzuela's agent.
Valenzuela, who won the Kentucky Derby and Preakness on Sunday Silence in 1989 and who has seven Breeders' Cup victories, for years was among the best riders based in Southern California. He also has a history of substance-abuse problems and suspensions.
His latest problem came Dec. 28, when the California Horse Racing Board terminated the conditional license under which he was riding. He had been arrested for allegedly driving under the influence of alcohol -- a violation of the terms of the condition.
Valenzuela is licensed in Louisiana and remains in good standing. He obtained a jockey's license in December in order to ride on Delta Jackpot day Dec. 7 at Delta Downs. Because of reciprocity among racing states, a licensee who is ruled off the track for violating racing rules in one state will be ruled off in every state. According to the Louisiana State Racing Commission, reciprocity isn't in effect in this matter because it doesn't involve a violation of racing rules.
Posted by rfb0318 Feb 4, 2008 2:29:02 PM
jcp says:
Am I missing something, or wasn't the Magna 5 pay-off pretty generous considering the prices of the 5 winners?
Posted by jcp Feb 4, 2008 2:09:48 PM
tlu_racing says:
The Magna 5 was an interesting wager when it arrived on the scene, but I agree that it needs some tweaking to become something viable.
1. Don't put the dog race tracks like Laurel and Golden Gate onto the ticket unless they offer a very high Allowance (N3X or above) or a Stakes race.
2. Offer $0.50 bettting. Even at the 50 cent level, this bet can get expensive but at the $2 level many players will just punt (especially if there are subpar races in the mix, such as the Golden Gate or Laurel races.)
3. Get over this stupid feud with TVG. The fact that the main TV station for horse racing, TVG, cannot cover the Magna 5 and the MEC tracks is a joke and a huge detriment to this sport. (HRTV is not a viable option when it is only available on one small outlet, DishTV - so don't think that that is the answer.) Let's face it guys, horse racing is a dying sport, with interests in other more dynamic forms of wagering gaining momentum. Having our sport with this chasm is ridiculous. The various factions need to come to some sort of detente and develop a revenue-sharing model that works for everyone. At this point, it looks like they are all fighting over the deck chairs on the Titanic. It's a sinking ship, guys. It will go down unless we come together as an industry, not continue this fiefdom and in-fighting.
Posted by TLU_Racing Feb 4, 2008 1:55:23 PM
michael_b_farber says:
Talk about slow times! A couple of years ago, the Prix Foy, a group race at Longchamp that is a major prep for Europe's most important race for older horses, the Arc de Triomphe, went in something like 3:12 for 2400 meters (just a bit shorter than 1 1/2 miles). There was a four-horse field and nobody wanted the lead; if I remember correctly, the first seven furlongs was run in something like 2:13 and they sprinted the rest of the way. It wasn't the turf course, which was good to firm. The same day, there was another 2400-meter prep for the Arc for fillies than went in something like 2:27 and change.
Posted by Michael B. Farber Feb 4, 2008 1:45:58 PM
jlwood says:
In watching the LaHabra, I see that SA posted a final time of 1:14+ while DRF and Equibase charts have a final time of 1:13.52. Any idea about the discrepancy? The internal fracions in print match up with those on screen.
Posted by jlwood Feb 4, 2008 1:04:35 PM
el_angelo says:
Stupid question: if the Magna 5 is such an abomination (and I agree that it's a terrible bet) why are you playing it at all?
Posted by El Angelo Feb 4, 2008 10:19:02 AM
arcstats says:
The issue of the Magna Pick 5 to generate the guaranteed pool value is just another line item in the long list of Magna failures. I challenge anyone to identify a Magna success story since this organization got involved in this business. From destroying Gulfstream, to building a fabulous turf course at a track (Laurel) which races all winter, to the failed management of Santa Anita....the list goes on and on. When this game is dead and gone, historians will look back and circle the date Magna tried to take control of everything as the beginning of the end. Again, name one thing this organization has done to benefit horse racing.
Posted by Arcstats Feb 4, 2008 8:31:12 AM
mlnj says:
Your comment about ReturntoKarakorum's victory in 1:15.20 reminded me about worst winning times which few keep track of. I once saw a genuine (non-fair) pari-mutual harness race go in 2:52. It was a 60 degree day in February at the old Green Mountain Trots. The frozen ground had thawed and the track was so muddy that the starting car couldn't be used. I had an opportunity to ask Stan Bergstein about whether the 2:52 was some sort of world record, and he told me no one had ever asked him such a question.
Posted by ml/nj Feb 4, 2008 8:13:30 AM
phil_j says:
Steve,
I am one player that would invest in the Magna 5 with more regularity if it were a $1 bet. I bet it the first week and managed to hit it, however, this weeks sequence was just too hard for my middle of the road bankroll to handle. So instead of getting my money I pass, it doesn't seem smart?
Posted by Phil J. Feb 4, 2008 12:05:26 AM
dylbert says:
To mix sports and metaphors -- Magna is clubhouse leader at screwing up proverbial steel ball with its race selection for Magna 5 wager. Newest gimmicks, except ones at Magna properties (i.e. Super High 5), focus on lower minimums wagers (10-, 25- & 50-cent) to broaden betting appeal.
Pass me another Frank's Energy Drink, please... Where are the yodeling models (another brilliant promotional ploy)?
Posted by dylbert Feb 3, 2008 11:30:39 PM
george_quinn says:
Everyone including Jeff need to look at the blogs from Jan 21 and my prediction. Hey Jeff who is laughing now HaaaaHaaaa. Giants outright Steven Crist go back to the blogs and check it out for yourself. Dated Jan 21 George in Lexington Ky.
Posted by george quinn Feb 3, 2008 11:03:16 PM
machouno79 says:
I know this blog is all about horse racing, but I'm a sports fan first and a New York one at that.. I can't believe the Super Bowl pass that Eli Manning just made to David Tyree... Absolutely unbelievable...
Posted by machouno79 Feb 3, 2008 10:27:14 PM
About
Steven Crist has been the Publisher and a columnist for Daily Racing Form since 1998. Previously, he covered racing for The New York Times from 1981-1990; was founding editor-in-chief of The Racing Times in 1991-92; and a vice-president of the New York Racing Association from 1994-97. He is the
author of several books including "Betting on Myself" and "Exotic Betting."
Recent Posts
Recent Comments
- Richard R on First Foolish Rule of 2009
- 92LNeck on First Saturday in January
- sero on First Saturday in January
- dom muscella on Inner, Inner Chicken Dinner
- Dave Bruder on First Saturday in January
- John O' on First Saturday in January
- Dan MacKenzie on First Saturday in January
- C on First Saturday in January
- C on First Saturday in January
- putting_green on First Saturday in January